The 1974 men’s soccer team advanced all the way to the NCAA Division III National Championship game, and became the first program in Swarthmore history to compete for an NCAA title. Led by coach Bill Stetson, the Garnet went 10-3-2 during the season. The Garnet opened the 16-team NCAA Tournament with a win over Lynchburg and then shut out Lock Haven and MacMurray in the quarterfinal and semifinal rounds. The Garnet’s quest for the school’s first NCAA title was stopped in the championship by Brockport State 3-1.
Members of the team include: Sam Agger, Gary Albright, Kenneth Andres, David Bachman, Dick Beppler, David Dougherty, Brad Gentry, Daniel Gordon, David Hahn, Jim Harvey, Maurice Kerins, David McElhinny, John McKitterick, Arthur Philpotts, J. Lawrence Schall, Joe Spirito, Thomas Spock, McWelling Todman, Johann Waplinger, and managers Marc Bisbing and Peter Siegelman.
Todman, who was already inducted into the Hall of Fame, was the MAC South's MVP and scored a tournament-best five goals.
Swarthmore's defense in 1974 only allowed 13 goals all season and recorded seven shutouts. The team was also co-champions of the MAC South that year.